But it is lenin's judgements on individual members of the centre committee that make his testament such a fascinating document leon trotsky, for example, is described as 'distinguished not only by outstanding ability he is personally perhaps the most capable man in the present cc, but he has. Two individuals dominated the russian revolution: lenin and trotsky historians have argued ever since who was the more important the information below should help you decide what you think, but be careful - it will be obvious from what i have written and how i have written it which of the two i think was the greatest. The relationship of lenin and trotsky is complicated but they were definitely friends at certain times and mutually favored eachother over stalin trotsky embraced marxism as a teenager and later dropped out of the university of odessa to help organize the underground south russian workers' union. Leon trotsky: lenin before october (april 1924) in addition to illuminating the critical stages of the great russian revolution through the person of lenin, trotsky's 1924 reminiscences cast light on the beginnings of the stalinist counter- revolution which it was nonetheless of exceptional significance. 1 trotsky said that “the revolution in russia came unexpectedly to everyone but the social democrats,” how did the social democrats know it would happen 2 likewise, what is the significance of radek's contention that, in contrast to lenin, trotsky was “excessively” concerned with proletarian state aid from the west. This week in 1917, in the pages of pravda, lenin issues a call for immediate unity with trotsky's mezhraiontsy group the unity of lenin and trotsky is also recognized by their enemies for the first time, newspapers in britain and the us fuse the names “lenin and trotsky” in their pages lenin and trotsky. Along broadly the same lines as trotsky, lenin proposed the new economic policy (nep), which essentially said, “now we must make a retreat trotsky is in a bloc with the democratic centralists and with a section of the “left” communists—therein lies the political significance of trotsky's action” [20.
Bolshevik strengths during the civil war, the bolsheviks had a number of key advantages over their opponents leadership the bolsheviks were extremely fortunate in the quality of their leadership, particularly in lenin and trotsky lenin had led the bolsheviks to victory in the october revolution throughout the civil war,. His organisational skills were quickly recognised and trotsky was chairman of the powerful petrograd soviet by the time of the november revolution during the actual revolution, trotsky organised the red guards in what was essentially a bloodless takeover of petrograd lenin charged trotsky with getting russia out of. Leon trotsky on lenin: leon trotsky's essay on vladimir lenin is historically significant not because it is trustworthy in its judgments but because it is unique here is one giant figure writing about another (who happened to have been his boss) at a time when both had been—until lenin's death in 1924—engaged in making.
Free essay: trotsky, lenin and stalin were all important in bringing the communist dictatorship in russia from 1917 - 1939 all three of them wouldn't be. Thus, it is clear that, like lenin and other bolshevik leaders, stalin's ultimate aim was collectivization of the land and industrialization of course, we cannot tell how lenin, or trotsky, zinoviev, kamenev or bukharin, would have ruled the ussr if they had won the struggle for power however, it seems unlikely, from what we.
But did lenin and trotsky's earlier suppression of party factions fatally secure his passage to total power mark hoskisson argues that the anti-stalinist left has underestimated the significance of 1921 in sealing the fate of the revolution stalin was the gravedigger of the russian revolution, as conscious. Explore the life of leon trotsky, whose intellect and leadership made him a change agent during the russian revolution, only to lose favor with lenin and incur the wrath of joseph stalin. Draconian enforcement of price controls was merely one of a plethora of tasks entrusted to the backbone of lenin's new regime: the secret police, or cheka, headed by felix dzerzhinsky its nucleus was trotsky's goon squad from the petrograd soviet, which almost immediately became an official organ of the government.
I've been wanting to do a comprehensive comparison of trotsky's theories and views held by him, to the theoretical contributions of lenin and the views held by him i'm also going to be occasionally referring to stalin's role and what his views were but because of time constraints i'll be focusing on lenin.
Résumé (eng) yuri felshtinsky, lenin, trotsky, stalin and the left opposition in the ussr, 1918-1928 the year 1928 can be considered a major line of demarcation in soviet history internally the country terminated the brief existence of nep, and the forced collectivization of peasant agriculture was begun in foreign. It is characteristic of their profound grasp of marxist method that both lenin and trotsky, independently of each other, immediately understood the significance of the kerensky regime and the attitude which the workers should adopt towards it lenin, in switzerland, and trotsky, in new york, simultaneously.
Trotsky argued that lenin's behaviour seemed unpardonable to me, both horrible and outrageous and yet disunite, and slaughter the proletarians of all countries by setting the wage slaves of one nation against those of another so as to benefit the bourgeoisie - these are the only real content and significance of the war. With reference to the view of at least 2 historians, compare and contrast the contributions of lenin and trotsky to the establishment and consolidation of a communist state in russia between 1917 and 1924 vladimir ilyich ulyanov contemplated lenin and lev davidovich bronstein contemplated leon trotsky were two. It consisted of vladimir lenin, leon trotsky and about 50 other committed agitators who wanted to overthrow the autocratic rule of the russian tsar their quarrels might have seemed minor at but of course its significance is seen differently according to different political viewpoints most people on the. In 1921, the sailors of the kronstadt naval base outside petrograd (st petersburg ) rebelled against the bolshevik regime the soviet regime succeeded in suppressing the uprising, but it has nevertheless acquired a strong symbolic significance for virtually all non-bolsheviks the kronstadt sailors adopted a political.